⚡ BLUF
Two Roads Tavern in Kitty Hawk is the local’s answer to OBX lunch- burgers and fried oysters that hold up against anything on the beach, at prices that don’t require a quiet moment of reflection when the bill arrives. Best for families and casual groups; if craft cocktails are on the agenda, you’ll want to eat somewhere else.
~9 min read · Last updated: September 2026
“Two roads diverged in a yellow wood.” Frost. We were thinking about lunch specifically, standing in the particular OBX decision where every third restaurant has a cartoon shrimp on the sign and a menu that promises the freshest catch in a building that opened in 1989. We followed a local tip instead. That has made all the difference.
At a Glance
- 📍 Name
- Two Roads Tavern
- 📌 Location
- Kitty Hawk, NC (Outer Banks)
- 💰 Price paid
- ~$20-30 per person (food, pre-tip)
- 📅 Date visited
- April 2026
- ⏱️ Time spent
- About an hour for lunch
- 🎯 Best for
- Families and casual groups who want honest OBX food without the tourist-trap markup
- ⭐ Our rating
- 3/5- solid local lunch, two standout dishes worth making the trip for
Is Two Roads Tavern Right for You?
Two Roads Tavern is for:
- Families who want a no-fuss OBX lunch where everyone leaves fed and nobody argues about the bill
- Anyone who thinks properly done fried oysters justify a detour off the main strip
- Groups looking for the local-favorite version of OBX seafood rather than the tourist-facing version
Two Roads Tavern is NOT for:
- Craft cocktail seekers- the bar does not go there
- Anyone who needs a quiet atmosphere; the noise runs moderate to loud at peak lunch
- Date nights or anything requiring a certain ambiance- this is bar-and-family casual, full stop
Our Experience at Two Roads Tavern
We found Two Roads Tavern the way you’re supposed to find places like this: a local (my Mom) said to go. Not a billboard visible from the highway, not a website that promises award-winning this or voted-best that: a person (or people in this case) who actually live on OBX (my parents) pointed us in this direction. So we went, together, as a family, which was nice.
The place sits in Kitty Hawk with a large parking lot out front. Take your time pulling in; there’s a bit more to navigate than it looks at first pass, especially in a rental. Inside: bar running along one side, booths along the wall, standard table seating in the middle, bright overhead lighting. The overall vibe is bar-and-family casual, cheerfully so and without pretense. We waited for a booth, because a table in the middle of the room is never the right answer if a booth is available. The wait was short.
The lunch crowd on an April Tuesday was solid- a mix of families, regulars posted up at the bar, the ambient energy of a restaurant that doesn’t need to advertise because everybody already knows it’s there. Service was attentive throughout and the staff knew the menu. The check arrived at the right moment without being rushed.
The Food
Two Roads Tavern is known for their burgers and oysters. We ordered both, which is either ambitious for a Tuesday lunch or exactly the right approach depending on your disposition. I’m going with right approach.
The fried oysters come in three varieties, each named for an OBX location- Kill Devil Hills, Kitty Hawk, and Nags Head. Each variety is the same oyster prepared differently; the name tells you how it’s dressed rather than where it came from. We worked through all three. They held up- nicely cooked, not overdone and not mushy, with the texture a fried oyster should have and that tourist-strip kitchens frequently miss when they’re frying to volume. These didn’t miss.
The Brie Mi burger: bacon, brie, grilled onions, sriracha mayo. It reads like something assembled by asking what ingredients people like and then stacking them, which is usually a warning sign. Somehow it works. The brie melts properly rather than just sitting there in a cold slab. The sriracha mayo adds heat without taking over. Around $20-30 per person covers food comfortably without cocktails.
We didn’t take any pictures of the food. Why? Because my Dad, and I love my Dad, is old-school. Like, “I want to eat those shared oysters and not wait for you to take out your stupid phone” old school. So, no photos. Close your eyes, imagine some of the nicest looking oysters Rockefeller you’ve seen, now you’re looking at the Oysters OBX (better than inserting some crappy AI generated image- you’re welcome). The Brie Mi- it’s a burger, with melted brie, a white cheese oozing out of the bun and dripping down the sides. There, you have your pictures.
The Atmosphere and Service
Noise level ran moderate to loud as the room filled in at lunch- nothing that made conversation impossible, but this is not a quiet corner-table situation. The booth seating is hard bench, typical for this kind of spot. We’d still wait for one over center-room seating every time; just know what you’re getting into.
Bar note: the drink offerings are functional. Canned and draft beer, mid-shelf spirits. You won’t be disappointed if you order a beer; you will be if you were hoping for something hand-crafted. Order the food, get something cold to go with it, and call the overall equation a win.
The Best Things
- The fried oysters: Three preparations, all properly cooked- not overdone, not mushy. The tourist-spot version of this dish tends to miss at least one of those two. These didn’t miss either.
- The Brie Mi burger: Bacon, brie, grilled onions, sriracha mayo. A burger that actually delivers on a menu description that could easily overpromise.
- The pricing: Roughly $20-30 per person for lunch in a beach market that could easily charge more. The value is not close.
The Most Disappointing Things
Nothing here fell down badly- it’s a local lunch spot doing the things a local lunch spot should, and doing the two that matter well. A few things are still worth knowing before you go.
- The bar: Functional, not interesting. Canned and draft beer, mid-shelf spirits- they serve the crowd that’s here, but they won’t serve you if you came in hoping for something more considered. Worth knowing in advance.
- Hard bench seating: Standard for this type of spot, not unique to Two Roads Tavern- but worth flagging if you’re settling in for a long lunch (Mom brought a pillow; she’s been here before). The booths are still worth waiting for; just bring patience rather than expectations of comfort.
- The lot takes a beat: The parking lot is bigger and busier to navigate than it first looks. Pulling in off Croatan Highway takes a second, especially in a rental- give yourself the moment so you’re not the car stopped sideways at the entrance.
Practical Information
- 🕐 Hours
- Open 11:30 AM to 9:00 PM daily, closed Wednesdays. Outer Banks hours can shift seasonally, so it is worth a quick check on the official site before a special trip
- 💰 Price range
- $$- about $20 to $30 per person for lunch, pre-tip
- 📅 Reservations
- Walk-in only, no reservations. We waited only a short time for a booth on a weekday lunch; expect longer in peak summer
- 🚗 Getting there
- 3833 N Croatan Hwy (US-158), Kitty Hawk, NC 27949. Large lot out front- take it slow pulling in off the highway
- 🅿️ Parking
- Free lot on-site
- 📞 Phone
- (252) 255-1980
- 🌐 Website
- Two Roads Tavern
Shana’s Take
“Those were some pretty dang good oysters. ‘Nuff said.” Shana doesn’t spend many words when the food makes the point for her, and she didn’t here. She’d order the oysters again without a second thought and wouldn’t reroute an evening to do it- which is the honest calibration for a walk-in lunch we landed on because a local said so.
Is Two Roads Tavern Worth It?
Yes, with a clear frame. Two Roads Tavern is not trying to be a destination dinner, and you shouldn’t ask it to be. As a local-tip lunch- fried oysters done right, a burger that overdelivers on its own description, a check that stays reasonable- it earns the detour off the main strip. Come for the food and something cold to drink, not for a cocktail program or a quiet table. What would move it up: a drink list worth ordering from. What keeps it honest at three: it’s very good at two things and ordinary at the rest.
Our verdict: Follow the local tip. Order the oysters and the Brie Mi, keep the drinks simple, and you’ll leave happy.
Have you been to Two Roads Tavern? We’d especially like to know whether the oysters hold up in peak summer, when the kitchen is busier than a quiet April Tuesday.
Found this helpful? 📌 Pin it for your Outer Banks trip planning.
Planning the rest of the trip around it? Our Outer Banks, North Carolina Travel Guide collects everything we publish from the island.
Frequently Asked Questions
Is Two Roads Tavern worth it?
Yes, for a casual OBX lunch. The fried oysters and the Brie Mi burger are genuinely good, and roughly $20 to $30 per person is fair for the beach. Skip it if you’re after craft cocktails or a quiet, dressed-up meal- that’s not what this is. Our rating: 3 out of 5.
How much does Two Roads Tavern cost?
We spent about $20 to $30 per person for lunch, pre-tip, without cocktails. It’s a solid-value $$ spot- burgers, fried oysters, and casual American food at fair beach prices. Prices may have shifted since our April 2026 visit, so check the current menu.
Do you need reservations at Two Roads Tavern?
No. It’s walk-in only. We arrived for a weekday lunch in April and waited only a short time for a booth. In peak summer season, expect a longer wait, especially if you want a booth over center-room seating.
What should you order at Two Roads Tavern?
The fried oysters and the Brie Mi burger. The oysters come three ways, each properly cooked- not overdone, not mushy. The Brie Mi (bacon, brie, grilled onions, sriracha mayo) overdelivers on its description. The bar is functional, so keep drinks simple and let the food carry the meal.
About the Author
Jeremy Smith, Retired USCG Captain (25 years). He spent his career making consequential calls under uncertainty. He and his wife Shana- also a retired Coast Guard aviator- bring that same rigor to every trip they plan, and to helping others get outsized value from award travel. About Jeremy & Shana · Work With Us