Turo vs a Rental Car in Hawaii- What Each One Cost Us

~9 min read · Last updated: September 2026

Disclosure: This post contains affiliate links. If you purchase or book through our links, we may earn a small commission at no extra cost to you. We only recommend gear and services we’ve personally used.

We landed on the Big Island around four in the afternoon. From experience, we knew the airport Budget rental car office was going to be a mess, so Shana and the boys stayed back for the checked bags and I went straight to Budget. The boys check bags. Shana and I are team carry-on, and I mention that only because it is the reason I was standing in the rental car building alone while the rest of my family waited on a carousel.

And, yes, Budget was a zoo. But, savvy travelers, register for FastBreak status and don’t be bashful about using it. I walked past a queue about twenty people deep, and I was in the car in ten minutes.

A week later on Oahu there was no counter at all. A woman named Corinne met me with a Toyota Sienna at the front of our hotel and handed me a set of keys.

At a Glance

🎯 What this covers

renting from an office on one island and booking Turo on the other, on one trip, with both bills

📅 When we did this

25 May to 9 June 2026, Big Island then Oahu, four of us

💰 Cost

$312.15 for seven days from Budget at Kona, $418.27 for 32 hours on Turo in Honolulu

⏱️ Time required

ten minutes at the counter with status, about a minute in the Turo app

📊 Difficulty

easy either way, and the hard part is the insurance question nobody asks out loud

👥 Best for

anyone who assumes their travel card covers a rental car, whatever kind of rental it is

⚠️ Watch out for

Chase Sapphire excludes peer-to-peer rentals, so on Turo the protection is a line item you pay for

Who This Is For

This is for the traveler who has a good travel card and has stopped thinking about rental insurance, because for years the answer has been the same: decline the counter waiver, the card has you. That was us. It was correct on the Big Island and it was wrong on Oahu, and the difference cost us ninety-two dollars and change.

It is also for anyone flying into Kona who has never heard of the Budget FastBreak lane. Not knowing about Budget FastBreak ahead of time will crush your soul when you do find out. Ask me how I know. I died a little that day when I did see the sign. I wept inside.

If you already run a spreadsheet on this stuff, you will not learn anything here except what our two specific bookings actually came to.

What You’ll Need

For the counter half: a rewards account with whichever company you are renting from, registered before you fly, because the whole benefit is walking past the line and you cannot sign up while standing in it. A card whose rental coverage is primary. A phone, for the walkaround video.

For the Turo half: the app, a driver’s license photo and a selfie holding it, and a decision about protection made before you get to checkout rather than at it.

For Hawaii generally: the GuideAlong app, because you bought it for this trip, right? If you did not, there is still time, so go ahead and do that. Then you can thank me in the comments. You’ll be the first one, and then I’ll add you to my Christmas card list.

The Process, Step by Step

Kona, the counter. The shuttle is like Fight Club, pure chaos. No one queues, no one waits, no one is civil. It’s like everyone knows the Budget office is Purgatory so they just want to get there and get started. Truly unpleasant.

Then you get to the Budget office and it is every bit of what you remember- the line, the lack of air conditioning, the too many people in line with their bags instead of having just one family member in line and the rest with the 10 oversized bags waiting patiently outside … you get the picture (because I didn’t take one). I do feel a little anxious using the FastBreak lane, always thinking to myself, am I in the right line, or is this line open? But when I’m out in 10 minutes and on the road, it is worth it. Just worth it.

At the rental counter they did not even ask about the collision damage waiver, which seldom happens, and I declined it anyway because the Sapphire Reserve is primary on my profile for auto rentals. Seven days, a Mazda CX-50, $312.15 all in on a $180.17 base rate. Perfect for the island. As for its condition, it’s Hawaii, you get what you get and you don’t throw a fit.

What I mean by condition, in this instance, is that apparently sunscreen stains on car seats are not considered damage in Hawaii. I took pictures of the stains anyway, because this isn’t my first rodeo and I’m not going to be responsible for someone else’s sunscreen stains. It wouldn’t be the first time a rental car attendant told me that the damage I pointed out was documented on the form, or noted somewhere in the system, only to get an email after turning the car in that I would be charged some exorbitant fee to have the damage repaired. Nope. I video my walking around the car each and every time (video and camera pick up things the eye does not).

From there we went straight to Waikoloa for dinner and check-in. As you drive to Waikoloa, you’re going to listen to the GuideAlong app, because you bought it for this trip, right? Dinner is picked out at the Island Gourmet Markets, or how we affectionately refer to it, Hawaiian Whole Foods. We’re big fans of always trying the local flavors, and Island Gourmet Markets is a local fav for us. We wrote up the Wailea one on Maui, where we always get the Loco Moco and it is more than enough for two to share.

What does a car get you on the Big Island? Well, without one it gets you a relaxing stay at a resort, and whatever is within walking distance of that resort, and whatever their free shuttle gets you to. Have a car and you get the whole island. And they don’t call it ‘the Big Island’ for nothin’. We have driven all over the island. On previous island visits, we drove to Hilo for Volcano National Park, to the top of Mauna Kea, out to Waimea and Hakalau, and I can’t even remember all the places we’ve driven. And every time we get in the car, we listen to GuideAlong the whole time. This trip? We drove to Costco a few times, gotta feed the boys. We drove down to Two Step to snorkel. And we drove up to Hapuna Bay to take the boys boogie boarding. Because this trip was more about relaxing and the boys don’t like to go see things. So we didn’t drive to do that, we drove to do water activities.

Driving around the Big Island can be maddening. I mean, the traffic. Slow. Yes, the speed limit is 45, or 55, probably not 65. But oh my, Island Time is real here and they take it seriously. I should be on vacation, but I have a vacation to take. Let’s go people. I have a vacation to take!

Oahu, no counter. Pardon the time warp, this won’t make sense now, but trust me when I tell you it makes sense later. Stick with me on the bigger picture. We were never going to rent a car on Oahu, because one of our kids lives in Honolulu and was going to drive us. As we were getting closer to the second half of the trip, the Oahu portion, Chuck gave us a heads-up that his vehicle situation was becoming, ah, I think he said: “somewhat unreliable.” Chuck is our car kid. He loves cars; he loves to tinker with cars. He always has a project car. He has … I digress and could go on for hours. I’ll summarize- for him to tell me he is concerned his vehicle situation isn’t reliable is huge.

So I ask him what is going on, and he says he doesn’t want us to spend more money, so he and his girlfriend are going to show us around that weekend in two cars instead of one. Which sounds terrible on a number of levels.

So Shana and I start to do our research. We don’t want to rent from the airport. Traffic on Oahu sucks, bigly. What other options are there? Enter Turo and Hui. Never heard of them? Neither had we. We asked our new friend, the Outrigger Regional Manager, and he had experience and opinions.

Eventually we decided on Turo. They deliver to the hotel and pick up from the hotel, we could use our resort credit to pay for the valet parking, and while Hui sounded like a cool option, being locked out of my car on the North Shore because my phone’s Bluetooth connection became finicky really wasn’t as cool as it sounded.

Corinne’s 2021 Toyota Sienna, delivered to the Outrigger Reef on Kalia Road. Six of us needed seats, which is what ruled out most of the alternatives before we started. Saturday ten in the morning to Sunday six in the evening, which is thirty-two hours, and which Turo bills as two days.

What We’d Do Differently

Two things, and neither is the one I expected.

The first is the insurance. I knew going in that Chase Sapphire excludes peer-to-peer rentals, so the Sapphire that had covered the CX-50 a week earlier was doing nothing here, and we bought Turo’s Standard Protection. Here is what that came to on a $418.27 booking: the car itself was $217.00, and protection plus roadside was $92.78. Twenty-two percent of that bill went to coverage the same card in the same wallet had given us free when renting from an established physical business. I would make the same call again. I would just stop describing Turo as the cheaper option in my head, because on a like-for-like basis it is not, and the vehicle damage protection is why.

The second is that we spent the whole planning phase optimizing around hotel parking. Thirty-two to sixty-five dollars a night is real money, and avoiding it was the reason the early plan had us renting for two separate day windows instead of one continuous booking. Then we paid sixty dollars for delivery to a hotel where the Amex Platinum Fine Hotels and Resorts credit was already covering the valet. The parking we designed the entire trip around never cost us anything. The sixty dollars bought exactly one thing, and it was not free parking. It was not having to go to the airport. Which is still a solid decision in my book.

Our Recommendations

If you are renting from a counter in Hawaii, register for the skip-the-line program before you fly and use a card with primary collision coverage. If you have not booked the car yet, compare what is actually available at Kona before you commit to a counter at all. That is the whole play. FastBreak turned an hour into ten minutes for us, and the first time we rented from Budget, before we knew, we waited over an hour. Now we do not wait. Ever.

And I will say the quiet part, because it is the honest part: the Budget experience is always chaotic, no matter what, and it just feels that way. Uncomfortable is the best it ever gets, and that just feels wrong. We use them anyway because they are usually the cheapest, they are reliable, and frankly, at this point in our time going to the Big Island, they are a known quantity. I know where the FastBreak lane is, and I will use it every time.

If you are booking Turo, decide the protection question before you open the app, because your travel card is not going to answer it for you. Price the protection into the comparison from the start rather than treating it as a surprise at checkout. And read the delivery fee for what it is. Ours was sixty dollars and it was worth it, but it bought convenience, not savings.

On which card to reach for, the answer flipped between the two islands. At the counter it was the Sapphire Reserve, for the primary coverage. On Turo the coverage card does not matter, so it was the Platinum, for the Fine Hotels and Resorts credit that quietly paid for the valet parking. Two rentals, one trip, opposite answers.

If you want that worked through against your own cards and a specific trip rather than in the abstract, that is the thing we do for clients.

More on getting around each island in our Big Island and Oahu travel guides, and if you are weighing what to spend points on at all, we wrote about when not to use points.

Found this helpful? 📌 Pin it for your trip planning.

Frequently Asked Questions

Is Turo cheaper than a rental car in Hawaii?

Not in our case. Seven days from Budget on the Big Island came to $312.15. Thirty-two hours on Turo in Honolulu came to $418.27, and $92.78 of that was protection. Turo bills by the day, so a half day costs a full one.

Does Chase Sapphire cover Turo?

No. Chase Sapphire excludes peer-to-peer rentals, so its primary collision coverage does not follow the charge onto a Turo booking. It is primary on a traditional counter rental, including standard minivans. On Turo you either buy the platform’s protection or check whether your own auto policy extends.

What does Turo delivery to a hotel cost?

Ours was $60 to the Outrigger Reef in Waikiki, on a $418.27 booking. That is not a parking saving. Price it as what it is, which is not having to get to the airport and back.

Do you need a rental car on the Big Island?

Yes. Nothing on the Waikoloa side is walkable, and the places worth driving to are an hour or more apart. We used ours for Costco runs, Two Step, Hapuna Bay, and on earlier trips Hilo and Mauna Kea.

---